QUOTE (ljk4-1 @ Dec 30 2005, 05:46 PM)
Was the human crew on the Discovery really necessary? I think HAL 9000 was right - humans just got in the way. It could have easily carried out the mission and likely better communicated with the Monolith than the humans could. What were those three guys in suspended animation supposed to do anyway?
FYI - Some of the book HAL's Legacy is online here:
http://mitpress.mit.edu/e-books/Hal/The guys in the hibernaculae - Kaminski, White, and Hunter (or not, depending on the source) - were officially the Jupiter Survey Team, but were actually the ET Contact Squad. Dave Bowman and Frank Poole were just jobbing astronauts, and could well have been treated as redundant, but the other guys were privy to the true goals of the mission. Heywood Floyd's message to Discovery was really just for Bowman and Poole - the others were spooks. For references, try Arthur C Clarke's
The Lost Worlds of 2001 and, of course, Jerome Agel's seminal work on 2001. As for poor HAL, he might have communicated with the aliens, but he'd not have made the sort of contact which was desired by them - they required an intelligence capable of transcending, and HAL was never going to do that, but Dave could...
FWIW, Clarke originally called HAl 'Athena'. This makes me somewhat wary of most Mars rovers...
Bob Shaw