QUOTE (JRehling @ Sep 22 2005, 05:29 PM)
It's tempting to take one's (subcommunity's) interest as a virtue, and then take it to be a necessary virtue, and then as something of a shame that others don't share the interest, but we're all guilty of not being interested in countless worthy things. Maybe someone else needs to do shameless things to draw our attention to their beloved thing. Are we then the problem?
I bristle a bit at the slightest hint that those who don't share an interest are in some sense wrong. If that's wrong, we're all wrong.
Thanks for your interesting remarks.
My own remark "Alas. This is all the problem." was simply to regret that so many people need "public relation tips" to be interested in an important domain.
Space exploration and astronomy are important things, as they are about the universe in which we are living, our home planet. But archaeology is important too, because it is about our moving past and origins. And music is an important thing too, as it speaks directly to our heart. Helping the poors is a moral duty, acting for environment is a survival necessity... Everything is important, and choosing one of this domain for our actions is only a matter of personnal choice, so long as this choice does not close our mind to the other important domains.
Playing baseball, football, etc, is just game, entertainment. It is less important. But our human nature is made in such a way that we need some entertainment. So we cannot say it is "bad" an we can abandon them only if we are engaged into some very demanding activity or very involving spiritual path.
So we must admit that other's main interest and involvement can be another science than ours, and even that it is not a science at all. Not to admit this would lead to some "scientific bigotry".
But we can also very sincerely regret that, for so many people, cheap entertainment is the only horizon, unsignificant music the only feeling, tabloids scandals the only issues, and one day they die without never having a glance to the stary skies or moving prrehistorical painted caves. Look out! we are moving at 250km/s! We are going toward a future society which we can even not imagine today!
So I perfectly understand the anger of Toma B with this image of Thetys turned into a baseball ball, but I am also able to laugh at helvick's silly gladiators (are they really made by the MER's team, or did you made them yourself for the forum?) (silly bet: stick one on the next MER to depart)
And with Doug Elison, I agree that we must in a way be "boddhisattva scientists" who go were people are, and communicate how they can, in order to help them to awake to more significant things. (Perhaps I went a bit further than Doug, but...)